The MasterBlog: Russia's Economic Privatization Plan
Subscribe to The MasterBlog in a Reader Subscribe to The MasterBlog by Email

MasterBlogs Headlines

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Russia's Economic Privatization Plan

Under the plan and new laws, the sales are divided into two categories: companies and assets. The state companies are 12-14 national champions that are up for privatization, including oil giant Rosneft and transportation monopoly Russian Railways. The state's assets that are up for privatization are a mixture of small companies and assets that the state does not deem strategic.

The private stakes up for sale in the "companies" category range from 10 percent to 49 percent, with most of the stakes on the smaller side. This is because the state considers these firms important enough to limit foreign control over them, but attractive enough to bring in some major international bidders. The government hopes the privatization of the main firms will bring in an estimated $29 billion by 2012.

Items in the "state assets" category either remained under state control since the Soviet days, fell under state control during the period of economic consolidation or were picked up by the state during the financial crisis. This category includes some 5,000 small companies and assets that are expected to be privatized before 2014. These firms and assets can be fully privatized, if the state wishes. The government hopes these privatizations will bring in an estimated $20 billion.

The Cash

In total, the Russian government hopes to bring in $50 billion — roughly the entire gross domestic product of neighboring Belarus — over three to five years purely by selling shares in companies and assets. And there is no shortage of sectors in need of that funding.

Theoretically, the cash is to be invested back into the firms being privatized. Most of the national champions are in desperate need of modernization, with much of their infrastructure suffering from decades of neglect and decay. Many of the state firms also have large-scale expansion plans for the future. But modernization and future expansion for most of the national champions is an incredibly expensive undertaking; $50 billion is nowhere near sufficient to meet these goals.

For foreign investors to be considered for involvement in the privatization program, they must first convince the Kremlin of their plans to modernize and expand the companies in which they invest, but there is an understanding that modernization is to be a joint private-public effort. Should the state renege on this understanding, it will find it difficult to find investors for future privatization rounds — remember, this is being done over five years so that Russia can ease itself into the changes, which means the state must continually express its own financial commitment to the effort to maintain investor interest.

This will be difficult, since the state actually plans to use most of the $50 billion of anticipated income to help plug the budget deficit, which Kudrin hopes to decrease greatly by 2014. Russia's forecast budget deficit for 2010 alone is $101 billion, which means $50 billion would not solve the budget problem this year, let alone through 2014. This would leave the government to its own devices to find the cash necessary to fund the modernization and expansion plans.

The Deals

The government has been secretive and cautious in proceeding with its privatization plan. This is in part because several of the state firms selected for privatization are resisting. Longtime Rosneft chief Sergei Bogdanchikov and a handful of his loyalists were sacked after they spoke out against the plan to privatize part of the firm. Nikolai Tokarev, chief of Russian pipeline monopoly Transneft, has also publicly objected to the privatization plan. Sberbank chief Sergei Ignatiev has also voiced concerns about the initiative; he would rather have shares of his firm up for public auction, where they could fetch more money, instead of a private Kremlin deal with a foreign player. However, the Kremlin wants to ensure it can control and monitor every foreign group gaining access inside Russia, which would be more difficult through a public auction.

The other reason for the Kremlin's caution is that it is still weighing estimations presented by Kudrin's economic team on whether the still-skittish financial markets would be willing to invest tens of billions in an economy that has a reputation for being less than safe. Even with the nervousness in foreign markets, quite a few foreign players are lining up to strike private deals with the Kremlin on stakes in these strategic firms.

In both the modernization and privatization programs, the Kremlin has used economic and financial deals in order to strike strategic bargains with foreign groups and governments. For example, according to STRATFOR sources, Italian energy firm Eni is interested in buying a stake in Rosneft as a way to give Eni more freedom to work in Russia and possibly secure other oil deals previously off-limits to the foreign firm. Similarly, sources say that U.S. firm Boeing and France's Thales are interested in a stake or a seat on the board of Russian Technologies, Russia's military industrial umbrella organization, which could be used to strike private deals for Russia's strategic titanium supplies.

Russia is also being cautious with the timeline for privatizing shares in its strategic state monopolies. For any national champion that will see more than a 10 percent stake privatized, the stake will be sold in multiple tranches in order to see if the first sale is successful and not destabilizing. This will give the Kremlin time to reconsider a second tranche if necessary. VTB, one of Russia's largest banks and the first big company the state is considering privatizing, will have its 24.5 percent stake sold in two tranches — first 10 percent and then the remaining 14.5 percent. Thus far, the Kremlin has been in private negotiations with U.S. investment firm Texas Pacific Group, whose chiefs traveled to Moscow in recent months to meet with First Deputy Prime Minister Igor Shuvalov to secure the deal. The first tranche is expected to sell for $3 billion, since VTB is worth $30 billion. According to STRATFOR sources, U.S. firm Merrill Lynch is conducting preliminary negotiations for the sale of the second tranche.

But in order for the multiple tranche plan to succeed, the Kremlin will have to prove after each tranche that there will be returns and results, which goes back to the government's need to find reinvestment funding. The Kremlin will also need to prove that it is willing to help with the cash shortfalls associated with the firms' modernization and expansion plans. Without any results, bidders will turn away from the remaining tranches for sale.

Another problem in striking deals with foreign groups is the difficulty the foreign firms could face in getting their shareholders to agree to such large deals with the Kremlin, which has proven in the past to be an unreliable business partner. Many firms looking to get back into Russia were burned by business deals there just a few years ago, when the state pushed them out or nationalized their assets.

In the end, the overall concern is that Kudrin's strategy for modernization and privatization has created an incredibly ambitious, intricate and fragile plan. There are many variables — bureaucracy, investor skittishness, markets' ability to handle the investments, possible backlash and Kremlin politics — that must align in a certain way in order for Kudrin's vision to materialize. If just one fails to fall into place, Russia's plan for an economically vibrant future could be at risk.

Get the STRATFOR Mobile App for breaking news and insightful analysis of global economic, military, security and political developments. STRATFOR gives you the Intelligence Behind the Headlines.

Sent from a wireless device.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Commented on The MasterBlog

Tags, Categories

news United States Venezuela Finance Money Latin America Oil Current Affairs Middle East Commodities Capitalism Chavez International Relations Israel Gold Economics NT Democracy China Politics Credit Hedge Funds Banks Europe Metals Asia Palestinians Miscellaneous Stocks Dollar Mining ForEx Corruption obama Iran UK Terrorism Africa Demographics UN Government Living Bailout Military Russia Debt Tech Islam Switzerland Philosophy Judaica Science Housing PDVSA Revolution USA War petroleo Scams articles Fed Education France Canada Security Travel central_banks OPEC Castro Nuclear freedom Colombia EU Energy Mining Stocks Diplomacy bonds India drugs Anti-Semitism Arabs populism Saudi Arabia Brazil Environment Irak Syria elections Art Cuba Food Goldman Sachs Afghanistan Anti-Israel Hamas Lebanon Silver Trade copper Egypt Hizbollah Madoff Ponzi Warren Buffett press Aviation BP Euro FARC Gaza Honduras Japan Music SEC Smuggling Turkey humor socialism trading Che Guevara Freddie Mac Geneve IMF Spain currencies violence wikileaks Agriculture Bolívar ETF Restaurants Satire communism computers derivatives Al-Qaida Bubble FT Greece Libya NY PIIGS Republicans Sarkozy Space Sports BRIC CITGO DRC Flotilla Germany Globovision Google Health Inflation Law Mexico Muslim Brotherhood Nazis Pensions Peru Uranium cnbc crime cyberattack fannieMae pakistan stratfor Apollo 11 Autos BBC Bernanke CIA Chile Climate change Congo Democrats EIA Haiti Holocaust IFTTT ISIS Jordan Labor M+A New York OAS Philanthropy Shell South Africa Tufts UN Watch Ukraine bitly carbon earthquake facebook racism twitter Atom BHP Beijing Business CERN CVG CapitalMarkets Congress Curaçao ECB EPA ETA Ecuador Entebbe Florida Gulf oil spill Harvard Hezbollah Human Rights ICC Kenya L'Oréal Large Hadron Collider MasterBlog Morocco Mugabe Nobel Panama Paulson RIO SWF Shiites Stats Sunnis Sweden TARP Tunisia UNHRC Uganda VC Water Yen apple berksire hathaway blogs bush elderly hft iPad journalism mavi marmara nationalization psycology sex spy taxes yuan ALCASA ANC Airbus Amazon Ariel Sharon Australia Batista Bettencourt Big Bang Big Mac Bill Gates Bin Laden Blackstone Blogger Boeing COMEX Capriles Charlie Hebdo Clinton Cocoa DSK Desalination Durban EADS Ecopetrol Elkann Entrepreneur FIAT FTSE Fannie Freddie Funds GE Hayek Helicopters Higgs Boson Hitler Huntsman Ice Cream Intel Izarra KKR Keynes Khodorskovsky Krugman LBO LSE Lex Mac Malawi Maps MasterCharts MasterFeeds MasterLiving MasterMetals MasterTech Microsoft Miliband Monarchy Moon Mossad NYSE Namibia Nestle OWS OccupyWallStreet Oman PPP Pemex Perry Philippines Post Office Private Equity Property Putin QE Rio de Janeiro Rwanda Sephardim Shimon Peres Stuxnet TMX Tennis UAV UNESCO VALE Volcker WTC WWII Wimbledon World Bank World Cup ZIRP Zapatero airlines babies citibank culture ethics foreclosures happiness history iPhone infrastructure internet jobs kissinger lahde laptops lawyers leadership lithium markets miami microfinance pharmaceuticals real estate religion startup stock exchanges strippers subprime taliban temasek ubs universities weddimg zerohedge

Subscribe via email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner